• 1851 - Joseph Scammon, Daniel W. Clark, Asa Googins
• 1852 - Joseph Scammon, Daniel W. Clark, Samuel Scammon, Jr.
• 1853 - George W. Springer, William Guptill, William H. Card
• 1854 - George W. Springer, William Guptill, Ambrose Scammon
• 1855 - William H. Card, Nathan A. Swan, Joseph W. Foster
• 1856 - George W. Springer, James M. Blaisdell, Theodore Bunker
• 1857 - James M. Blaisdell, Joseph W. Foster, David Hadley
• 1858 - John West, Samuel Wasson, Sherman Smith